Amazing Thread Breaks Down All 18 Kinds of Disney Movie Songs
Reporter Justin McElroy cracked the code of Disney‘s musical magic. Disney animated films and their soundtracks are a staple of many childhoods. The studio frequently adapts fairy tales, myths, and other cultural stories, alongside original plots. However, while seemingly few connections exist between the plot and theme of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs and Pocahontas, for example, they do have excellent songs in common.
It also helps that Disney often collaborates with the same musicians multiple times. Alan Menken is probably the most famous, having crafted songs for several Disney animated classics in the 1990s. These include The Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, and Aladdin. Menken has also worked on newer Disney films like Tangled and Enchanted, as well as several of the studio’s live-action remakes. He’ll return for the new Little Mermaid, working with Lin-Manuel Miranda. In fact, Miranda is already beginning to form a similarly long-lasting relationship with Disney, writing songs for Moana and starring in Mary Poppins Returns.
Now, Justin McElroy, a reporter for CBC Vancouver, suggests there is more than meets the ear in Disney songs. He uncovered patterns that structure them, explaining there are categories of songs into which animated features fall. His impressive Twitter thread is thorough and lays out the evidence well. It’s not enough that he defines 18 categories and examples, he delves deeper to cite the types of Disney characters who’d sing certain songs, as well as the number of times each category song appears. McElroy finally summarizes the entire grouping experience into a visual graphic, titled The Disney Songbook Table Of Elements. Check out the thread below:
This Is The Movie (26 entries):
– It summarizes the theme of the film or says its title several times
– It is at the beginning of the film (exception: Beauty and the Beast, Pocahontas)
– It is first sung by a chorus, or an unseen or minor character (exception: Pocahontas) pic.twitter.com/yEk048reux— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
I’m The Villain (18 entries):
– It’s sung by the villain (exception: Cruella De Vil)
– It always comes after the I Want songs
– It usually expresses the villain’s desire, but can also be mocking the main character pic.twitter.com/DQRtChVjRC— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Cheer Up, Kid! (17 entries):
– It’s always sung by a supporting character who likes the protagonist
– The theme is always positive
– It generally builds up to dancing or fevered choreography, with an element of “let’s put on a show!” pic.twitter.com/CIhAbY1IIt— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Here’s My Deal (21 entries):
– It expresses a character’s their joie de vivre, often in a bragging way
– While the I Want song is about inner desires, this expresses outward joy
– It is sung by the main character or clear second, soon after we meet them pic.twitter.com/PO8GRbN7Ri— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Here’s Their Deal (13 entries):
– A character or two best friends is being described by another person or group
– Usually sung shortly after we meet the character (or Aladdin’s case, reinvention of the character)
– Often has elements of a montage & and an unseen singer pic.twitter.com/ZGufU78L2z— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
It’s Dancing Time! (11 entries):
– Sort of self-explanatory
– The protagonist never instigates the dancing, and if they’re in the scene, the dancing sort of happens around them
– generally serves as an intermission for the movie pic.twitter.com/njjEWruyaa— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Montage (13 entries):
– It’s a montage. You know what a montage is.
– There are no great montage songs, only acceptable ones
– There were no montages before Hercules
– Half the songs Phil Collins wrote for Tarzan and Brother Bear were montages, and that was a poor choice pic.twitter.com/DNyyIZ7akx— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
We Won! (8 entries):
– Is about celebrating that something good has just happened, or is about to happen
– Typically happens at the end of the movie
– Is never sung by the main character, but they’re often around
– Three Winnie the Pooh songs! pic.twitter.com/241uccwtGa— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Here’s A One Note Character (7 entries)
– Is sung by or a minor character who usually only appears once (exception: the harp in Fun and Fancy Free)
– Is essentially a short “I Want” or “Here’s My Deal” song by someone you don’t care about
– Three Alice in Wonderland songs! pic.twitter.com/PkUFSHoxLT— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Life Lesson Time! (6 entries)
– Advice on how to live one’s best life is given
– It is always directed to the main character (exception: Scales and Arpeggios)
– I’ll Make A Man Out Of You is here
– Which is weird, because that’s a great song! And great songs don’t live here pic.twitter.com/jJOPQL2hpk— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Every single song in a Disney animated feature fits into one of these 18 categories.
And there are 18 columns in the Table of Elements.
I think you know what that means.
— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
This is the Disney Songbook Table of Elements.
It contains every single original Disney animated song, put in categories, organized by time era, and colour-coded for specific films. pic.twitter.com/Ay8s410ytZ
— Justin McElroy (@j_mcelroy) May 18, 2020
Impressively, The Disney Songbook Table Of Elements includes all phases of the company’s film production, including the Golden Age in 1937-1959, the Xerox Age from 1961 to 1988, the Disney Renaissance from 1988 to 2000, and the ongoing Revival Era. It makes sense that few memorable songs fall into the outlier category, and “Problematic” is a graveyard where numbers like “The Siamese Cat Song” go to die. Though not regular features, the outliers appear in more than six films each, signaling the importance of registering the categories.
Recognizing anomalies is also important because sometimes the outliers produce standouts like “I’ll Make a Man Out of You.” The act of tracking and defining the genres of song highlights the consistency of Disney productions from the company’s inception to now. It also finds the through line for which songs draw children and certain performers. Here’s hoping Disney sticks to its formula, while creating new animated films with “I Want,” songs to entertain kids for years to come. The Disney Songbook Table Of Elements bridges the viewing experience of Disney animated classics across generations.
Source: Justin McElroy
About The Author