Jim Carrey: 5 Ways He’s Better As A Dramatic Actor (& 5 Ways He’s Best In Comedy)

Renowned for his outlandish physical comedy, rubber facial expressions, and infectiously energetic screen presence, Jim Carrey has made a name for himself as one of the most revered comics of the last several decades. He’s given audiences some of the most iconic characters in cinematic history, and recent appearances on SNL and in Sonic the Hedgehog prove that he hasn’t lost his comedic touch.

Along with his propensity for the hilarious, he’s also developed a collection of films that showcase his considerable dramatic talents. In such screen gems as Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind and The Truman Show, he’s demonstrated that his exploration of the human condition extends beyond the bizarre and into a wellspring of emotions. But where do his strengths truly lie?

10 Dramatic Actor: His Emotional Range

To look at films like Me, Myself, & Irene, The Mask, or Dumb and Dumber, it would be easy to conclude that Carrey doesn’t have a large emotional range. Those characters are mostly a study in gonzo storytelling, but in his dramatic films, he portrays people that are vulnerable and authentic.

Films like Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind reveal that Carrey can express a soulful melancholy, the sort of ache that gnaws at the psyche of anyone who’s ever been in the sort of turbulent love a rom-com film wouldn’t do justice. Even to fans of his comedic performances it remains one of his best films.

9 Comedic Actor: His Facial Expressions

Other than the late great Robin Williams and Jonathan Winters, there aren’t any comedians who have as malleable a face in comedy as Jim Carrey. His face appears to be made out of rubber, and he can contort it into every conceivable look and expression possible.

Even under the pounds of facial prosthetics necessary for him to wear in A Series of Unfortunate Events, The Grinch Who Stole Christmas, and The Mask, it’s his creative countenance that carries his characters.

8 Dramatic Actor: Biopics And Historical Films

From Man on the Moon about the inane exploits of sardonic funnyman Andy Kaufman, to The Majestic about a screenwriter in the Golden Age of Hollywood who rediscovers his patriotism during the Red Scare, Carrey’s involvement in dramatic films that are focused on biographies and moments in American history is poignant and provocative.

When permitted, he fully embodies the idiosyncrasies of real living people, and when necessary, the eccentricities of fictional people, but without the tropes and two-dimensional confines of his comedic performances.

7 Comedic Actor: His Physicality

Jim Breuer, Sebastian Maniscalco, and a few comedians in the last few decades have approached Carrey’s prowess in the arena of physical comedy, but even their most rambunctious performances would be hard to top Carrey at his zany best.

From Ace Ventura’s signature strut, to The Mask’s samba moves, Carrey imbues his characters with movements that define their personhood. In many cases they become inseparable, which makes him a particular star at doing impersonations and impressions of other people.

6 Dramatic Actor: More Complicated Roles

Comedic films can be incredibly complex, but the sort of intricacy they espouse often comes from the mechanics of their gags. Sometimes Carrey’s comedic roles inform his dramatic roles, and they become profoundly complicated.

In films like The Truman Show, Carrey is required to portray a man who has no idea his life is a reality show, and his narrative arc covers both the absurd and the heart-wrenching. In the series Kidding, he plays a children show’s host who has an existential breakdown, and must deal with the aftermath of being depressed in a world that expects him to make it laugh.

5 Comedic Actor: Iconic Performances

From skit series like In Living Color where Carrey created memorable characters like Fire Marshall Bill, to films like Ace Ventura: Pet Detective, Bruce Almighty, and The Mask, there are few comedians who have given audiences so many distinct and recognizable creations.

Carrey’s performances in these films not only helped him develop his signature sense of style and expression, but also cemented his status as a comedic legend. The lines from his most hilarious characters have even worked their way into the pop cultural zeitgeist.

4 Dramatic Actor: Timing

Timing is everything for a comedian, and many a joke has fallen flat because the punchline has been rushed. The relationship between the comic and their audience is a mercurial one that requires finesse and skill, and Carrey has been able to successfully carry it over into dramatic roles.

His use of timing is expertly used in films like The Number 23, which required a suspenseful build of momentum to carry the tension of its conspiracies, and in showcasing the right amount of fear and aggression as Scrooge in A Christmas Carol. 

3 Comedic Actor: Variety

While there are those who might denounce Carrey as nothing more than a one note comedian who plays the same character in every film, they will not have paid very close attention to his filmography. A quick scroll shows just how diverse his comedy performances really are.

He’s done superhero comedy (Batman Forever, The Mask), slapstick comedy (Dumb and Dumber, Ace Ventura: Pet Detective), philosophical comedy (Bruce Almighty, Liar Liar), social satire (The Truman Show), fantasy comedy (A Series Of Unfortunate Events, Earth Girls Are Easy), and many more.

2 Dramatic Actor: Realism

Comedy can tackle “the big questions” by presenting them through a jocular lens, softening their bite and making them more palatable for certain viewers. While Carrey has used comedy for such purposes before, his dramatic roles have let him explore topical concerns with authenticity.

Take I Love You, Phillip Morris, where Carrey plays a cookie-cutter cop who realizes he wants to be truthful to himself. He accomplishes this by ironically becoming a con-man who, during a stint in prison meets Phillip Morris (Ewan McGregor), an unlikely romantic partner and accomplice. Instead of relying on tired stereotypes of LGBTQ+ characters that don’t age well, the sartorial and dramatic tone to the film allows Carrey to be far more genuine.

1 Comedic Actor: Surrealism

Comedic roles allow for the exploration of some of life’s most bizarre questions. By treading into the absurd, they’re able to often reveal a lot about the human existence by exposing life’s farcical sense of irony. Carrey has often selected roles that focus on surrealism in an effort to highlight certain societal themes and messages.

Me, Myself, & Irene on the surface might appear like a debauched satire, but through Carrey’s dual performance can also be viewed as an attempt to grapple with the unintentional comicality of mental illness. The same can be said of Yes Man, where he taps into the often self-created imprisonment of societal expectations.

About The Author

Kayleena Pierce-Bohen
(1344 Articles Published)

Kayleena has been raised on Star Wars and Indiana Jones from the crib. A film buff, she has a Western collection of 250+ titles and counting that she’s particularly proud of. When she isn’t writing for ScreenRant, CBR, or The Gamer, she’s working on her fiction novel, lifting weights, going to synthwave concerts, or cosplaying. With degrees in anthropology and archaeology, she plans to continue pretending to be Lara Croft as long as she can.

More From Kayleena Pierce-Bohen