Sabrina The Teenage Witch: Every Season Ranked (According To Rotten Tomatoes Audience Scores)

Before Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina captivated fans on Netflix, Sabrina The Teenage Witch had its own take on the Archie Comics characters. Fans of the Netflix show will see certain similarities. Sabrina Spellman lives with her Aunt Hilda and Aunt Zelda after no longer being able to stay with her parents and her journey through a new magical world as a witch had a much bigger 90s sitcom vibe.

Sabrina grows up throughout the series and tackling teenage drama becomes adult angst during the last three seasons. As Sabrina matured, the show did too, introducing new characters to interact with Sabrina and freshen up the series. But which season did the fans prefer the most? Let’s look at the Rotten Tomatoes audience scores to get a clearer picture.

8 Entire Show: 75%

Sabrina Spellman believed she was just an ordinary girl…until her sixteenth birthday. Having recently moved in with her Aunt Hilda and Aunt Zelda, Sabrina was not prepared for the monumental differences about to take over her life.

But, when Sabrina has to juggle mortal life and be a witch, it calls for comedic hijinks. During seven seasons, Sabrina grows from a young high school student struggling to control her powers to a young adult with a better grasp of magic, at least, for the most part. The series was also greatly helped by its essential supporting characters, Hilda, Zelda, Salem, Harvey, Josh, Libby, Roxie, Morgan, and more.

7 Season 5: 67%

At last place, season five had the difficult task of introducing Adams College and Sabrina’s new roommates, Roxie, Morgan, and Miles. After spending four seasons with Sabrina’s high school gang, season five had to work overtime to ensure the new supporting characters were just as amusing and intriguing as the previous ones.

Sabrina grows up more this season, spending time outside of her house and adjusting to life at college. However, season five isn’t lacking in romance either. After breaking up with Harvey, Sabrina had not gone out, still upset over the breakup along with her continued feelings for Josh.

6 Season 7: 73%

The final season of Sabrina The Teenage Witch, shows Sabrina living with Salem, Morgan, and Roxie in the Spellman’s house. With Hilda and Zelda both gone, Salem and Harvey take over as Sabrina’s main confidants about magic.

Sabrina’s interest in journalism starts her in a professional job. Magic still chaotically exists in Sabrina’s life as she attempts to keep that aspect of her life a secret from Roxie and Morgan. Harvey also plays a major recurring role and adds drama to Sabrina’s already frantic life after he admits he still has feelings for her. The series finale concludes with Sabrina and Harvey getting back together and realizing that they are soul mates.

5 Season 4: 73%

The senior year of high school brings about a lot of questions about the future. Sabrina Spellman is not exempt from any of them. Which college will she attend? Will Sabrina go to college at all? Several questions arise about what will come next.

But, the present holds plenty of drama and struggle too. In Sabrina’s romantic life, she is conflicted between her steady boyfriend Harvey, and Josh, the older guy who works at the coffee house. Sabrina even goes as far as to lie to Harvey and kiss Josh, resulting in their breakup. Still, Sabrina must worry about Brad, Harvey’s friend with a Witch Hunter gene.

4 Season 1: 73%

Being an average teenager is already hard enough, but add being new to the school and having magical powers, and that’s plenty to worry about.

At school, Sabrina is introduced to a brand new group of kids, including Libby (a long-time bully), Jenny (a short-lived close friend), and Harvey (Sabrina’s eventual boyfriend). Season one is filled with magical mischief as Sabrina tries to use magic to her advantage.

3 Season 6: 75%

The second season to feature Sabrina in college comes with a surprising pairing. While Sabrina is enjoying her relationship with Josh, she is shocked to discover that Morgan is dating Harvey. Season six reincorporates Harvey into Sabrina’s life by being Morgan’s boyfriend. However, since Harvey knows Sabrina is a witch, their friendship becomes more developed as Sabrina no longer has to hide magic from him.

However, Sabrina and Harvey need to keep Sabrina’s secret from Josh and Morgan, which causes plenty of drama and jealousy in their respective relationships. Season six is also the last to include Hilda and Zelda as main characters. Zelda gives up her adult life to give Sabrina a chance at true love, and Hilda leaves after getting married.

2 Season 3: 79%

What is the family secret? That is the question Sabrina struggles to answer throughout the season. Sabrina is visited by various relatives, all of which hold a clue to the family secret.

Unfortunately, Hilda, Zelda, and Salem can not help Sabrina achieve the answer. So, when Sabrina finally solves the riddle during the family reunion in Hawaii, every Spellman has an evil twin, Sabrina must compete to prove she is the good counterpart.

1 Season 2: 82%

Season two improved the already successful show by adding new elements of magic. However, it also included a lot of craziness to Sabrina’s mortal life as well. Sabrina’s friend Jenny is replaced by Valerie, a new girl in school.

However, that is only the beginning. With Sabrina’s seventeenth birthday, she must prepare for her witch’s license. When she initially fails, Sabrina is sent to boot camp in preparation to retake the test. Sabrina also finds herself in a love triangle between Harvey and a witch, Dashiell.

About The Author

Lindsay Press
(274 Articles Published)

Lindsay Press is a freelance writer. As a graduate of SUNY Purchase College with a degree in Screenwriting and Playwriting, Lindsay has loved television shows and movies since childhood. In addition, she loves to create stories and enjoys dystopian futures, teen drama, and fantasy worlds.

More From Lindsay Press